Yes or No - Decision Maker

Yes or No Generator

Ask your question, press DECIDE, and go with what it says. Every answer is a fair coin: exactly 50/50, and it never remembers the last one.

?

The DECIDE button, in your pocket

The app is this button and five more ways to hand a choice over: a coin flip, a decision wheel, a number generator, spin the bottle, and a finger picker that settles who goes first when everyone puts a finger on the screen. Seven colour themes, 18 languages, works offline. Free to download.

How it decides

When you press DECIDE, the page asks your browser's cryptographic random number generator for a number and turns it into one fair bit: yes or no, each exactly as likely as the other. It is the same source browsers use to make encryption keys, rather than the quick Math.random() that most web toys use, and it is read in a way that keeps both answers equally likely. There is nothing else in it. The question you type has no effect, the previous answers have no effect, and there is no secret preference for the answer the page thinks you want.

Streaks are normal

Press it ten times and you will probably see the same answer three or more times in a row: that happens about 83% of the time with a fair coin. Four in a row turns up in nearly half of all runs of ten, five in a row in more than one in five. The list under the button shows your last answers and your longest run, so you can see it for yourself. People expect randomness to alternate more than it does, which is why a fair generator feels rigged and a rigged one, one that avoided streaks, would feel fair.

What it is really for

A yes or no generator is not better at deciding than you are. What it does well is take a trivial decision out of your head, or out of the group, so that nobody has to be the person who chose. That is the whole job: lunch, the film, who drives, whether to have the second coffee. Keep it to choices where either answer is fine. If the answer it gives makes you wince, that is useful too: it means you had already decided.

Questions

Is it really 50/50?

Yes. Each answer is one random bit from your browser's cryptographic random number generator, the same source used to make encryption keys, read without bias. Nothing weights it, nothing nudges it towards the answer you seem to want, and it does not balance itself out after a run.

Why did I get the same answer three times in a row?

Because that is what fair randomness looks like. In ten presses, the chance of seeing the same answer at least three times in a row somewhere is about 83%, four in a row about 46%, and five in a row about 22%. A generator that never produced streaks would be the rigged one.

Does it read my question?

No. The question box is only there so you can see what you asked next to the answer. It is not sent anywhere, it is not put in the page's address, and it has no effect on the answer, which is decided the same way with or without it.

Should I let it decide something important?

No. It is for decisions that are not worth the time you are spending on them: what to eat, which film, who goes first. For anything that matters, a random answer is not advice. What it can do even then is show you how you feel: if a NO disappoints you, you already knew what you wanted.

Is this different from flipping a coin?

Not in the odds: both are a fair 50/50. The difference is only that the answer is the one you asked for, yes or no, rather than heads or tails you then have to map onto it. The app has both, as well as a decision wheel for more than two options.

Get occasional updates

New features, tips, and the occasional announcement. No spam.

More from DCZT